top of page

Why Do Most Business Culture Change Efforts Fail?

Watch the video. To keep up with all our videos, just subscribe to our Youtube channel and hit the notification button.

Read the Transcript below if you'd prefer. 

hey it looks like we're live now and 00:02 this is something we're to be doing more 00:04 often here at the ultimate why to try to 00:06 connect you with topics of culture 00:08 change employee engagement and 00:10 leadership development so today's topic 00:12 is why do leadership or management 00:16 change initiatives fail now McKinsey and 00:22 Associates a large research group 00:24 in the management area has done a lot of 00:27 research in fact recently in 2018 they 00:29 did a survey of 3199 executives about 00:34 their management change initiatives how 00:37 well they did and guess what 70% of them 00:39 failed 00:40 so that's a fairly high failure rate and 00:43 you can see that kind of failure rate is 00:46 something that discourages a lot of 00:48 these initiatives and a lot of delving 00:50 into leadership development so they 00:54 wanted to investigate what were the 00:55 factors involved in making this 00:57 successful rather than a failure so they 01:00 came up with four things so ready to 01:03 write these four things down first is a 01:05 compelling change story 01:07 the second is role modeling the third is 01:10 reinforcement mechanisms and the force 01:13 is capability building so those are the 01:17 four factors that went into the 30% 01:21 success rate according to their research 01:24 and I wanted to go back over these a 01:27 little bit more detail 01:29 according to the article and give you 01:30 some correlation with with some of the 01:33 thinking that we have here feel to the Y 01:35 so the first is compelling story of 01:38 course we've all heard how narrative is 01:40 very important in to the the Millennial 01:43 Generation 01:44 and quite frankly it's something it's 01:46 part and parcel of all of the 01:49 generations maybe the millennial 01:50 generation it's just a little bit more 01:52 attuned to that then the rest of us are 01:54 that the awareness that we have a story 02:01 that sort of compels us as individuals 02:03 it's our core beliefs if I believe that 02:05 things are okay I wouldn't want to 02:09 with change so if my change story 02:11 actually sees changes of threat that's 02:15 probably something that leads towards 02:16 the 70 percent failure rate people have 02:18 this in nurse reports I'm getting my 02:19 paycheck I'm doing well in my job if I 02:23 become the sole individual that begins 02:26 to change do things differently then 02:28 that I could be the problem I could be 02:30 the source of the ire of my community so 02:34 we need a corporate compelling change 02:37 story another thing that they said that 02:38 was kind of interesting is it doesn't 02:40 really work for a change story to come 02:43 down from on high you know just like a 02:45 we're gonna change because of this if 02:49 management imposes the change story it 02:52 doesn't become accepted they said they 02:53 had a story where it they showed that if 02:56 people wrote down their own lottery 02:57 number versus were given a lottery 02:59 ticket there were five times more likely 03:01 to hang on to that lottery ticket which 03:04 was an interesting little story saying 03:06 that you know to prove the point that if 03:08 you create something yourself then it 03:09 becomes precious to you you hold on to 03:11 it so that's why they were doing this 03:15 change story and the change story needs 03:18 to come from the bottom up from each 03:20 individual not just from top down and 03:22 it's tap into ultimate wise ultimate 03:27 meanings in their lives 03:28 so those are a couple of things that we 03:30 do it at the ultimate why we do have a 03:32 program that that develops change story 03:35 from each individual each team from the 03:37 bottom up and then we also connect that 03:41 change story to very deep level ultimate 03:43 wise and each individual's life 03:46 connected to their traits and to their 03:48 values and to how they do life so those 03:51 are very important things in the change 03:53 story the compelling story of change the 03:56 next is role modeling which is also very 03:58 important leadership on all levels needs 04:02 to be engaging in in the change effort 04:06 so yeah a lot of times you get a very 04:08 high degree of buy-in from top 04:10 management but then low-level management 04:13 it's kind of ho-hum about buy-in and 04:15 becoming a role model other studies that 04:18 weren't mentioned in this article that 04:20 are interest 04:21 is that if someone sees two or three 04:25 other people doing an action once 04:27 they're far more likely to actually 04:30 repeat that action then if they see a 04:33 leader doing it three times so it needs 04:36 to be a role model that is also within 04:38 the leadership but also within the 04:40 culture pervasively so that's those are 04:43 two things that the ultimate why model 04:46 actually we wanted to inculcate into our 04:49 model is to have that multi level buy-in 04:52 and processing and we also wanted it to 04:56 be sort of very wide and broad in the 04:59 role modeling aspect of things so that's 05:01 one of the things that we're doing in 05:03 the third which is like unto that is 05:04 reinforcement mechanisms so a lot of the 05:08 curricula that we evaluated before you 05:10 know buying into our curriculum or 05:12 creating our curriculum rather was that 05:15 it be sort of like a one-time event 05:16 where we tell you here are the 16 things 05:18 you need to do I just get them done and 05:21 Bob I have fun we found that to be 05:25 troubling because I've been involved in 05:27 change efforts and unless they are sort 05:30 of consistent and ongoing and reinforced 05:33 it's just gonna be a binder and a shelf 05:35 that that gets forgotten shortly and 05:38 then the fourth is capability building 05:40 you need to have some sense of growth in 05:43 the areas that are necessary for someone 05:48 to to expand their life into the 05:51 challenges that are being created by 05:53 this new change story so if you don't 05:55 give them a compelling way to get into 05:58 that or some tools and resources to do 06:02 that then ultimately your change efforts 06:05 will fail or become or will struggle and 06:09 again the ultimate why has a section in 06:11 our matrix called the promise where 06:13 people are develop developing their own 06:15 mission and their own goals and their 06:18 own actions for like a nine week period 06:21 where they're trying to grow into 06:23 something new and so we give a lot of 06:25 tools into growth because part of 06:28 connecting and how positive connection 06:31 is is being able to grow into things 06:32 people want 06:34 they're giving and their relationships 06:37 to expand into positive areas so those 06:40 are four compelling areas and I'll 06:41 repeat them again though the compelling 06:42 change story role modeling reinforcing 06:46 mechanisms and capability building those 06:48 are the four things that lead towards 06:50 the 30% success rate according to 06:53 Mackenzie so we were really excited by 06:57 this article because if the research 07:00 really reinforced the approach that 07:02 we're taking here at the ultimate why so 07:03 we'd love to continue this conversation 07:05 with you we're going to be doing more of 07:08 this kind of conversation next week on 07:11 our YouTube channel and we'll probably 07:13 try to post that on our site as well as 07:15 as sort of a webinar that you can join 07:18 in on we'll be emailing this out and 07:21 communicating with you each week 07:23 hopefully a little bit more about how to 07:26 connect and how to continue the 07:28 conversation and of course if you want 07:30 to continue the conversation personally 07:31 with us you can reach out to us and we'd 07:33 love to talk more with you about your 07:35 change efforts your culture development 07:37 your employee engagement challenges your 07:40 leadership development challenges and 07:43 this is our mission here is to make 07:46 every place a great place to work at so 07:49 please stay in touch and thanks for 07:51 tuning in

bottom of page